Cookies on Businesscar

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on the Business Car website. However, if you would like to, you can change your cookies at any time

BusinessCar magazine website email Awards mobile

The start point for the best source of fleet information

Renault Megane vs rivals - cost analysis

Date: 18 August 2016   |   Author: Debbie Wood

Renault is a brand on the up. The recent launches of the Kadjar and Captur crossovers have proved highly successful in both retail and company car markets, helping to bring a much-needed resurgence in popularity for the French firm.

Now it's time for one of its biggest sellers, the Megane, to make its UK comeback. A grand total of 6.6 million Meganes have been sold in Europe since it was first launched in 1996, 560,000 of which have found homes here in the UK.

Megane

When your biggest rivals are the Ford Focus and Vauxhall Astra, stealing a share of the company car limelight can be quite a challenge. However, generous equipment levels and a decent-size boot enable the fourth generation of the Megane hatchback to stand out, and it's also arguably better looking than its mainstream rivals too, featuring a wide front end and striking new lighting signature.

There's a choice of six trims. We've picked the Megane in mid-range Dynamique S, and there's a whole host of equipment available for the £20,345 P11D price. Among the highlights are satnav, 17-inch alloys, a reversing camera, dual-zone climate control, upgraded sound system, stylish ambient lighting, automatic lights, and a portrait-style 8.7-inch touchscreen infotainment system.

Megane 2

Interior quality, however, despite a substantial uplift in this latest model, still lags behind the Focus and Peugeot 308 hatchbacks somewhat with a few cheap plastics lurking. Longer and lower than the car it replaces, space up front is plentiful, although legroom is still restricted in the rear.

Engine-wise, there's a choice of two petrol and two diesels. For the best in terms of running costs, the 1.5-litre diesel is the one to pick with an official combined fuel economy of 74.3mpg and the lowest CO2 emissions of the range at 96g/km, slotting the hatchback into a 19% BIK tax band for the current 2016/17 tax year.

Megane 3

To drive, the Megane is composed and comfortable over long distances, and the smooth diesel offers 110hp plus 260Nm of torque, which proves excellent at cruising speeds, albeit feeling a little underpowered when you want to overtake or gain speeds quickly on the motorway; the 0-62mph sprint officially takes 11.3 seconds, the slowest of the five cars selected here.

Although it's the newest in our list, disappointingly, SMR and fuel costs are not as competitive as we'd expect, and despite an uplift in residual values over the outgoing model, the Megane still lags a little behind the competition with its 29.6% figure. Whole-life costs of 46.8p better the Focus at 47.6p, though, and are only slightly higher than the Honda Civic's 45.7p.

Although not class-leading in any of the key cost metrics, the Megane has some key strengths, making it a worthwhile consideration in this overcrowded segment. Its stylish looks and generous equipment levels are among its biggest selling points.

Renault Megane Dynamique S Nav dCi 110  - CPM: 46.8p

P11D: £20,345
Power: 110hp
Fuel consumption: 76.4mpg
CO2 (BIK): 96g/km (19%)
BIK 20/40%: £64/£129
Vehicle excise duty: £0
National insurance: £1769
Insurance group/cost: 21/£3210
Warranty: 4yrs/100,000mls
Boot space: 434 litres

RVs: 29.6%/£6025

8.8% uplift over previous generation, but still lags behind most of its main rivals

Fuel costs: £4010

Not the worst of the five but fuel consumption is still quite high

SMR: £1976

SMR is costly, despite the car offering one of the longest service intervals

To read the latest road test of the Renault Megane click here

Ford Focus - CPM 47.6p

02 Total Ford Focus Sales Since Launch Exceeds 1.75 Million Units In July

Ford's Focus has been the biggest-selling company car for many years now and it's not difficult to see why. It's the Ronseal of the automotive world, and there are few cars that will tick as many boxes.

That said, the new Vauxhall Astra and Renault Megane significantly close the gap on running costs, with both cars achieving better whole-life costs.They're cheaper than the Focus's P11D value too.

Hugely practical and accomplished to drive, the Focus's well-weighted steering and excellent ride quality make it an ideal motorway commuter, plus the 1.5-litre diesel here is smooth and refined. It's arguably the blandest in terms of the design of the five cars, though, and doesn't come as well equipped either, missing out on parking sensors and automatic lights and wipers as standard.

Ford Focus 1.5 TDCi Zetec S Nav

P11D price £21,540
Vehicle Excise Duty £0
National Insurance £1873
Fuel consumption 74.3mpg
CO2 (tax) 99g/km (19%)
BIK 20/40% per month £68/£136
Warranty 3yrs/60,000mls
Boot space 316 litres
Engine size/power 1499cc/118hp

RVs: 31.0%/£6674

Decent RVs only bettered by the Vauxhall Astra and Honda Civic

Fuel costs: £4123

According to official figures, the Focus is the thirstiest on fuel

SMR: £2072

Disappointing SMR costs make the Focus most expensive here

To read the latest review of the Ford Focus click here

 

 

 

 

 

 

Peugeot 308 - CPM 47.0p

05 Peugeot _308

One of the best all-rounders in the segment, the 308 is a practical and stylish hatchback. When coupled with this 1.6-litre diesel, the 308 is the most fuel-efficient too - with a combined economy figure of 91.1mpg, its closest rival, the Astra, achieves 85.6mpg.

Despite the frugality, the 308 is the quickest of the cars here and the only one to complete 0-62mph in less than 10 seconds.

Residual values are disappointing, though, at just 24.9%, which almost completely discounts the fuel gains for overall whole-life costs.

Inside, the 308 hatchback's minimalist dash design is one of the best in the segment. In Active trim standard kit includes a 9.7-inch touchscreen system and DAB radio, but it's not as generously equipped as some of its rivals.

Peugeot 308 1.6 BlueHDi Active

P11D price £20,725
Vehicle Excise Duty £0
National Insurance £1716
Fuel consumption 91.1mpg
CO2 (tax) 82g/km (18%)
BIK 20/40% per month £62/£124
Warranty 3yrs/unlimited
Boot space 470 litres
Engine size/power 1560cc/118hp

RVs: 24.9%/£5150

Very disappointing figure and far off the competition

Fuel costs: £3363

Best of the bunch for fuel costs due to official combined 91.1mpg figure

SMR: £1588

Not the best for SMR, but still better than the Focus and Megane

To read our review of the 308 hatchback click here

Honda Civic - CPM 45.7p

 NEW Hondacivic

It doesn't take the lion's share of sales in the segment, but the Civic has a lot to offer as an alternative to its mainstream rivals. Distinctive design features like an oddly shaped front end and glass tailgate will divide opinion, but running costs-wise there's little to argue with as the Civic hatchback is well and truly up there with the competition.

Only the Astra offers better RVs and whole-life costs, despite the Civic being the most expensive of the five.

Practicality has always been one of the Civic's strongest assets and it offers the biggest boot with 477 litres. Behind the wheel is futuristic and modern and there's a good use of materials throughout. Equipment is also good with satnav and parking camera plus front and rear sensors among the standard kit.

Honda Civic 1.6i-DTEC SE Plus Navi

P11D price £21,695
Vehicle Excise Duty £0
National Insurance £1796
Fuel consumption 78.5mpg
CO2 (tax) 94g/km (18%)
BIK 20/40% per month £65/£130
Warranty 3yrs/90,000mls
Boot space 477 litres
Engine size/power 1597cc/118hp

RVs: 32.0%/£6950

Only the Astra betters the Civic for RVs

Fuel costs: £3902

The Honda sits in the middle of the pack for fuel costs

SMR: £1413

Not the best, but SMR still much lower than the Focus and Megane

To read our review of the Honda Civic click here

Vauxhall Astra - CPM 34.9p

Vauxhall -Astra -297799 Copy

The seventh-generation Astra brought a renewed focus in interior quality and a raft of new technology when it was launched last year. It's also the cheapest of our list, with the best residual values and lowest whole-life costs.

This 1.6-litre diesel offers some excellent running costs figures too, and thanks to its 200kg weight loss the car feels more nimble on the road. Interior roominess is another plus, although the Astra can't compete with most of the competition when it comes to boot space.

Value for money is a key strength and there's plenty of useful kit on offer in this fleet-specific Tech Line trim with satnav, cruise control, LED daytime running lights, an eight-inch colour touchscreen system, automatic lights, DAB radio and Bluetooth all included.

Vauxhall Astra 1.6 CDTi Ecoflex Tech Line

P11D price £18,290
Vehicle Excise Duty £0
National Insurance £1514
Fuel consumption 85.6mpg
CO2 (tax) 88g/km (18%)
BIK 20/40% per month £55/£110
Warranty 3yrs/60,000mls
Boot space 370 litres
Engine size/power 1598cc/108hp

RVs: 32.7%/£5975

Vauxhall leads the pack for residual values

Fuel costs: £3579

Just the 308 is cheaper when it comes to fuel costs

SMR: £1352

Longer service interval helps make the Astra the cheapest of our list

To our review of the Vauxhall Astra click here

Best of the rest

Model              P11D             CO2             CPM
Hyundai i30 1.6 CRDi Blue Drive 110 SE Nav          £19,540           94g/km            42.9p
Skoda Octavia 1.6 TDi 110 SE Business          £19,595          99g/km            43.3p
Mazda 3 1.5d SKYACTIV 105 SE SNav          £19,440          99g/km            43.7p
Mini Clubman One 1.5D 116          £21,320           99g/km            44.0p
Seat Leon 1.6 TDi Ecomotive 110 SE Technology          £20,680           94g/km             44.8p
Kia Ceed 1.6 CRDi 134 3 6-spd          £20,640           99g/km             45.4p
Nissan Pulsar 1.5d 110 N-Connecta          £21,110           94g/km             46.2p
Toyota Auris 1.6 D-4D 112 Business Edition          £20,940          108g/km             46.8p
Citroen C4 1.6 BlueHDI 120 Flair          £19,895            95g/km             47.6p
VW Golf 1.6 TDI 110 Bluemotion          £22,275            89g/km             47.8p

Related articles:

Cost analysis - Jaguar XE

Cost analysis - Mazda CX-3

Cost analysis - Vauxhall Astra

Whole-life costs: The hard sell



Share


Subscribe