Latest report: Mazda3 long-term test
18 February 2020
Author: Sean Keywood
|Mazda3 Saloon 2.0 180 GT Sport |
|P11D price:|| £26,470|
|As tested:|| £27,460|
|Official consumption:|| 50.4mpg|
|Our average consumption:|| 42.2mpg|
6th Report: Engine of the future?
It is a few months now since our Mazda3 saloon arrived, so it seems like a good time for an update on its most innovative feature, the Skyactiv-X engine. To recap, this is a non-turbo petrol engine with a diesel-style compression injection system, with an added mild hybrid boost, which Mazda says is designed to offer the best of both traditional petrol and diesel engines, with improved efficiency.
When I first drove the car, my concern was that a lack of low-down torque compared with a turbo petrol or diesel motor would mean needing to mash my right foot into the carpet to make any progress, but from behind the wheel at least this hasn't seemed a major issue. OK, I have to shift down a gear a bit more on motorways than in the (now discontinued) diesel 3 I ran previously, and the odd road such as the steeply uphill dual carriageway out of Maidstone requires some serious throttle work, but most of the time it is a non-issue.
While you do need to work it hard to reap the full performance suggested by the 180hp official output figure, when driving normally around town or on level A-roads the performance is perfectly adequate for unflustered progress, and it feels no different to the typical sort of turbo petrol engine you might find in rivals of a similar size and price - a driver used to one of those wouldn't find it underpowered.
As we have mentioned before, the big advantage of the Skyactiv-X on paper is its low official CO2 emissions figure, which stacks up very well against said petrol rivals and also non-RDE2-compliant diesels. However, the concern was that the price for this would be paid in fuel bills, and while it hasn't felt like I have been ragging the engine unduly, its current test average of 42.4mpg is a bit of a disappointment compared with the 50.4mpg official WLTP figure and the 58mpg I previously achieved in the diesel. In the Skyactiv-X's defence, however, my recent schedule has been very light on long motorway runs, so this has mostly been achieved on rush hour commutes. With the 3 still having a couple of months left to run on its time with us, hopefully it can get a bit closer to the official figure by the time it departs.
5th Report: A wheely good idea
The past few weeks, with the arrival of overnight frosts and winter approaching in earnest, has made me grateful for two things. Firstly, that I am no longer a local newspaper reporter who round about now has to write hundreds of articles with 'festive fun' in them. And secondly, that our Mazda3 has a heated steering wheel.
I have never run a car with this feature before, and now that the weather merits its use I think it can be filed alongside Toy Story 3 in the category of 'things I didn't know I needed until they arrived'. Having walked the couple of minutes it takes to get to where I park in the morning, and then potentially had to spend time de-icing the windows, it becomes the height of luxury to place my cold hands on the also chilly steering wheel, then think 'oh yeah!' and press the heating button.
The system doesn't make the wheel furnace-hot, just comfortably warm, like wearing gloves, and that is exactly what is needed. Along with the car's heated seats (both are standard with GT Sport spec), it means the discomfort of December commuting is greatly reduced.
Another feature of our 3 I didn't expect to appreciate as much as I do is its boot. Saloons have been out of favour in the lower-medium segment for some time now, with hatchbacks having a seemingly obvious practicality advantage, but a couple of recent trips to the airport have made me see its benefits. There is the space - 444 litres, nearly 100 more than the hatch, and still extendable further by folding the seats down - and perhaps less obviously the security. When having to leave luggage in the car for days in an airport car park, it is extremely reassuring to know it is locked away in a separate boot that thieves can't simply smash their way into through a window.
It is just a little bit of peace of mind that takes an extra bit of stress out of travelling.
4th Report: Battery blunder
I didn't have the best of starts with our Mazda3 saloon, for reasons entirely of my own making. Having got used to relying on automatic headlights, I hadn't realised that the delivery driver had left the switch in the manual 'on' position, and promptly drained the battery over a weekend, having somehow failed to twig why the car was chiming at me as I got out of it (and missed the warning message on the dash).
The incident did, however, lead to two noteworthy observations. The first, a negative, is how much of a literal pain it is to open the car when the keyless entry system isn't working, due in this case to the flat battery. A manual key is hidden inside the fob, but it lacks a proper handle, meaning you have to awkwardly grip the metal shaft to use it. I initially failed to find the slot it goes into, possibly as it was pouring with rain at the time, but even once I was informed it was hidden under the driver's door handle it was a fiddly and frankly painful process to force the key in and turn in. Having unlocked the car and confirmed my headlight mistake, I then couldn't get the key to turn the other way to lock it again (although in hindsight a thief would hardly have got very far with a flat battery).
The second, more positive observation is that when the breakdown van turned up, its driver proclaimed himself very impressed with the appearance of the car itself, and this is an opinion that I have come to share. I said when I reviewed the saloon last month that it wasn't as strikingly styled as the 3 hatch, and I still think that is true, but away from a launch event surrounded by hatches and on normal roads among regular traffic, I have decided it is a very handsome car in its own right. It also stands out from the hatch I ran previously thanks to cream (officially stone) upholstery, a £200 option. Personally, I am not sure this is better than the black trim the hatch had, but some who rode in the hatch found it slightly claustrophobic, and the cream does give the interior a much more light and airy feel. Many will no doubt welcome this, although I can't imagine families with children would find it very practical.
3rd Report: Into the red
Regular readers may notice that for this month's update, our Mazda3 appears to have changed colour and grown a bigger boot. Well, rest assured this is not linked to my previous complaints about grey cars (although I do prefer the new red). The reason for the change is that Mazda unexpectedly discontinued the diesel version of the 3, the hatchback version of which we were running previously, saying there had not been enough demand for it from customers. Therefore, we have switched to running the new Skyactiv-X petrol engine in the also-new 3 saloon.
You can read more about this bodystyle and powertrain combo in our recent review, and I am particularly interested to see how this innovative engine performs during day-to-day use. However, I think it is worth noting here how impressive I found the diesel engine to be, and why I think it is a shame it didn't attract more demand from buyers. For starters, with a test average of 58mpg it managed to not only match but exceed its 56.5mpg official combined fuel economy figure, which despite the new WLTP testing cycle supposedly making this easier than under the old NEDC regime, is still impressive. It is not like I was on economy runs either - the figure was achieved from occasional long-distance motorway drives mixed with my regular rush hour dual carriageway and town centre commute. The fact that such a strong real-world economy figure is possible without a great deal of effort shows exactly why we at Business Car believe diesel is still the best option for so many fleet applications.
Not only that, but the engine's refinement was good too. Having tested a couple of relatively noisy diesel rivals, it was a revelation to step back into the Mazda and find that with the radio on the engine was close to inaudible, even when accelerating down a slip road to join a motorway. Together with the economy it made the diesel engine an impressive package. Mazda reckons the Skyactiv-X engine has diesel-like characteristics; the upcoming back-to-back comparison will be an ideal test of those claims.
2nd Report: Keep your head up
When experts debate why UK road death figures are broadly static, despite improvements in crash protection and the arrival of safety systems such as autonomous emergency braking, the issue of driver distraction often comes up. The concern is whether the proliferation of both in-car screens and smartphones is making drivers take their eyes off the road more. Happily, this is something our Mazda3 addresses, thanks to its head-up display, or Active Driving Display in Mazda parlance, which projects key information onto the windscreen directly in front of the driver. At first I was worried this might be annoying, or a distraction in itself, but in fact a few weeks into our test it's one of my favourite features of the car (for those who don't agree, it can be switched off).
Among the info displayed is the car's speed - which means I don't have to look down at the instrument panel when negotiating speed limit changes such as the ones on smart motorways - the current speed limit, cruise control settings, and alerts from the various on-board safety systems, such as blind spot monitoring and collision warnings. Most usefully of all for me, it also displays sat-nav instructions. As someone who gets annoyed by the voice function in sat-navs and always has it off, I run the risk of missing turnings in most cars if I don't remember to look down at the screen, but having the next instruction displayed in my eyeline makes this next to impossible.
But the head-up display doesn't stand alone - it's part of a highly impressive overall infotainment package. The 8.8in central screen features sharp graphics and an easy-to-navigate interface, and it's operated by a rotary controller in the style of BMW's iDrive set-up. This works very well and is easy to get used to, meaning it wasn't long into our time with the 3 before I could flick between, for instance, the sat-nav map and the radio screen without having to take my eyes off the road. The only slight annoyance is that the screen isn't a touchscreen - fine when driving, but it means addresses have to be entered into the sat-nav letter-by-letter via the rotary controller, which is a bit time consuming.
1st Report: It's a shame about grey
When I first saw pictures of the new Mazda3, I thought it was one of the most striking-looking new cars to be launched this year. From a front three-quarter angle in particular, something about the perfectly rounded shape of the roofline, combined with the smooth sides and lack of fussy detailing, seemed to give it a clean, futuristic, almost spaceship-like appearance, which isn't something I would normally expect to be saying about a family hatchback. Therefore, I was excited to find that I would be running one on the Business Car fleet for the next six months.
However, there was an initial disappointment - the colour. Now, I am well aware that, according the SMMT, grey is currently the most popular shade for new cars in the UK, and if you are reading this magazine you will know a major reason why - restrained colour choices typically mean more solid residual values. But ask a child what they think of grey cars and they will say they are boring, and they are dead right - I would much rather have had a red one like in the first pictures when the car was launched. Still, it does represent an ideal test of the Mazda's looks - can it stand out for me despite the colour? The good news is that, on initial impressions, it just about does, with some well-deployed black detailing lending a hand. I'll be interested to see whether my opinion shifts one way or the other as I get used to it day-to-day.
The other thing to note about our 3's grey paint is it's actually the only optional extra the car comes with - in fact metallic paint is the only cost option Mazda is offering. Everything else with the 3 is standard kit, and with the high-end GT Sport equipment grade on our car - only one step down from the top of the range, - there is quite a lot of it. From the spec sheet, initial stand-out features include a head-up display, which is actually standard throughout the range (it will be interesting to see if this proves useful or a gimmick). Our car also has adaptive cruise control, which I am hoping will be a stress-saver on busy motorways. There is also a feature I have not had on a car before, a heated steering wheel - though obviously it will be a few months before I am able to properly assess its usefulness. Otherwise, first impressions of the interior are that it lives up to the promise of the exterior styling - it is a nice place to sit, with attractive swooping lines, good-quality materials on the dash and switchgear, leather seats, and a raised central armrest/storage bin arrangement that integrates with the centre console in a way that is reminiscent of the German premium brands, and on initial impressions doesn't suffer for the comparison.
Under the bonnet? Well, while the decline in diesel car registrations shows no sign of abating, we still think they make sense for high-mileage company car drivers, so our 3 has the single diesel option Mazda is offering, a 1.8-litre with 116hp. It is not the engine in the range that Mazda is making the most fuss about, however; instead, the firm is hyping the new Skyactiv-X, a 2.0-litre, 180hp petrol set to arrive in showrooms in October. As well as being more powerful than the diesel, the Skyactiv-X will also, thanks to slightly lower CO2 emissions and the BIK surcharge on diesel cars, sit five company car tax bands lower. Clearly, then, this will be very tempting for drivers, but fleet managers will likely be more impressed by the official fuel economy advantage the diesel still holds. My time with our 3 will hopefully shed some light on whether this is an argument managers can reasonably hope to win.